Picture this: You’ve spent years in medical school, balancing rigorous coursework, clinical rotations, and board exams, and now, the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) Match process stands between you and your dream residency. 

How do you ensure that your rank order list sets you up for success, not disappointment? The stakes are high, and the process can feel overwhelming, but you’re not alone. 

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about crafting the perfect rank order list—debunking common myths, mastering the Match algorithm, and offering expert tips to help you confidently navigate every step. 

Let’s dive in!

Need Professional Help? Schedule a Free Consultation with Jack Westin NOW!

What Is the NRMP Match Process

The NRMP Match Process is a system that pairs medical graduates with residency programs, ensuring both applicants and programs are matched based on mutual preferences. Here’s a step-by-step guide to how the process works:

1. Registration: It starts in September, when applicants must register on the NRMP website and prepare to submit applications via the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS).
2. Application and Interviews: From October to January, programs will invite you to interviews. This is your chance to assess whether a program’s values, culture, and training opportunities align with your career goals.
3. Rank Order List (ROL): In February, applicants submit a Rank Order List (ROL), ranking residency programs in order of preference. Remember to rank based on where you truly want to train, not where you think you’ll get accepted, as the Match Algorithm is designed to favor the applicant’s preferences.
4. The Match Algorithm: The NRMP uses a highly structured algorithm to match applicants with programs. This algorithm is crucial to pairing applicants and programs with mutual interest based on applicant rankings of programs and program rankings of applicants.
5. Match Week and SOAP: 

Match Week: During Match Week, applicants find out on Monday whether they have matched. Those who are fully matched can wait until Friday for the official reveal of the program they matched with.

SOAP: If you don’t match, the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) provides a second chance to secure a residency. SOAP also begins on Monday, allowing unmatched applicants to apply to up to 45 programs. Interviews are conducted via quick phone calls, and offers are extended on Thursdays.

Overview of the Match Algorithm

The NRMP Match Algorithm is a mathematical process that matches medical residency applicants and residency programs based on mutual preference. Here’s a breakdown of how it works:

• Applicant-Proposing System: The algorithm starts by attempting to place each applicant into their highest-preferred program as indicated on their Rank Order List (ROL). It first tries to match you with your top-choice program. A tentative match is made if the program also ranks you highly and has available spots.
• Tentative Matches: If an applicant is tentatively matched to a program, that match remains “tentative” until all applicants and programs have been considered. If another more preferred applicant comes along, the algorithm may “bump” a lower-ranked tentative match and assign that applicant to their next most highly preferred program.
• Program Preferences: The NRMP algorithm simultaneously considers the program’s rank list. If the program has ranked another applicant higher than you, they will receive priority for the available slot. However, if no other applicant is ranked higher than you in that program, the match becomes final.
• Final Match: The tentative matches are finalized once all the applicant and program rank lists have been processed. This means you will match to the highest-ranked program on your list that also prefers you.
• Key Takeaway: The system is designed to prioritize the applicant’s preferences. Therefore, you should always rank programs based on where you genuinely want to train, not based on guessing where you think you’ll match. Attempting to “game” the system by trying to predict the program’s ranking of you is not a winning strategy.

See More: Residency Application Consulting by Jack Westin

How to Prepare Your NRMP Rank Order List

1. Researching Residency Programs

When researching residency programs for your NRMP Rank Order List, tools like FREIDA, program websites, and alumni networks are essential for making informed decisions. 

FREIDA offers access to over 13,000 ACGME-accredited residency programs, allowing you to refine searches by specialty, location, and even visa sponsorship options. 

You can filter programs based on key criteria like work-life balance, board score cutoffs, and patient populations, which are crucial in selecting a program that aligns with your goals.

Additionally, program websites provide more detailed information about resident life, curriculum, and faculty. These sites often include important insights on on-call schedules, rotations, and benefits, which might not be as easily accessible elsewhere. 

Finally, leveraging alumni networks can provide first-hand experiences from those who have gone through the program, offering an inside look into the program’s culture and long-term career outcomes.

2. Evaluating Program Fit

When evaluating program fit for your NRMP Rank Order List, consider key aspects such as program culture, values, teaching approach, and patient populations.

Start by assessing the culture of a residency program, as it directly impacts your training experience. Look for programs that align with your personal and professional values, where you feel supported by mentors and colleagues. Research has shown that programs with strong mentorship and resident satisfaction lead to better learning environments and work-life balance​.

Next, consider the values of the program. Ask yourself: Does this program prioritize research, clinical training, or patient care? These values often shape the day-to-day experience of residents. You want a program where the goals of the faculty align with your own long-term aspirations.

The teaching style is another crucial factor. Some programs offer more hands-on training with frequent faculty interaction, while others may emphasize independent learning. Determine which teaching style suits you best by talking to current residents and reviewing the program’s curriculum structure.

Lastly, pay attention to the patient populations you’ll serve. Diverse patient populations can expose you to a wide range of medical conditions, offering a more comprehensive training experience. High-volume centers, for example, provide broader exposure to both common and rare cases, which is beneficial for honing your skills. In rural residency programs, trainees may encounter patients with limited access to medical care, presenting a unique opportunity to manage cases of uncontrolled disease and gain experience with underserved populations.

3. Self-Reflection

When preparing your NRMP Rank Order List, self-reflection is essential to aligning your personal and professional goals with the right residency programs. First, consider your specialty choice—some specialties are more competitive, like dermatology or orthopedic surgery, so you may have to be flexible with other factors, such as location. 

According to data from the AMA, location is crucial for 75% of applicants who prioritize geographic proximity to family or a desired living environment. Choosing a location where you’ll thrive personally can reduce stress and boost your well-being during residency​.

Additionally, program size can affect your experience. Larger programs may offer more diverse patient cases and better research opportunities, while smaller ones often provide closer mentorship and a tighter-knit community. This balance is personal—some residents prefer high-volume centers for hands-on experience, while others prioritize personal attention and strong mentorship.

To make the best decisions, create a scoring system for each program based on your priorities, such as work-life balance, research opportunities, and personal ties to the location. Then, weigh these scores against your gut feeling after interviews. Combining systematic evaluation with your intuition will help you build a rank list that maximizes both career satisfaction and personal happiness​.

How to Craft Your NRMP Rank Order List

Step 1: Debunking Myths

When crafting your NRMP Rank Order List, it’s essential to debunk some common myths that can lead applicants astray. One of the biggest misconceptions is that you should rank programs based on where you think you’ll match rather than your actual preferences. 

The NRMP algorithm favors applicants’ choices, so you should always rank programs in your true order of preference, not based on guesses about where the program ranked you. 

Trying to outsmart the algorithm doesn’t improve your chances of matching but may result in you being placed in a program you’re less happy with.

Another myth is that ranking fewer programs increases your chances of matching your top choices. In fact, the opposite is true. Research shows that applicants with longer rank lists are more likely to match. The average successful candidate ranks 11.22 programs, whereas those who go unmatched average 4.21 programs.

Therefore, it’s important to rank all programs where you’d be happy to train, even if they weren’t your initial top choices.

Step 2: Ranking Strategy

When crafting your NRMP Rank Order List, it’s important to balance your dream programs and more realistic options. This strategy will increase your chances of matching successfully while also aiming high. Start by ranking your dream programs at the top, even if they feel out of reach. The NRMP algorithm prioritizes your preferences, so always rank based on where you want to match, not where you think you’ll get in.

However, it’s equally crucial to include backup options or “safety programs” where you would still be happy to train. 

Programs that align well with your qualifications but are less competitive can be your safety net, ensuring you don’t go unmatched. This balanced approach helps maximize your chances while keeping your aspirations intact.

Step 3: Geographic and Lifestyle Considerations

When creating your NRMP Rank Order List, geographic and lifestyle considerations should be key in your decision-making process. The location of your residency will significantly affect your work-life balance, support systems, and overall happiness during training. According to the NRMP survey, 75% of applicants cite geographic location as a major factor when ranking programs.

Consider the cost of living in the area when evaluating residency programs. While residents in cities may earn higher salaries than those in lower-cost areas, the higher living expenses in urban settings like Boston or San Francisco can offset these increased earnings. Understanding the balance between salary and living costs can help you choose a location that supports your financial well-being during residency.

Additionally, the location may significantly impact your personal well-being. Proximity to family, friends, and other support systems often plays a crucial role in resident satisfaction and resilience. Being close to loved ones can provide essential emotional support, helping you cope with the challenges and demands of residency training.

Lastly, think about how the lifestyle and community of a location align with your personal preferences. Some applicants thrive in metropolitan environments with diverse patient populations, while others prefer smaller, quieter areas with close-knit communities​.

How to Submit Your NRMP Rank Order List

Registration: If you haven’t already, register with NRMP by late January to avoid a late fee. You can still register after this, but must do so by late February, which is the final Rank Order List (ROL) submission deadline.

Rank Your Programs: Starting in early February, you can begin entering your program preferences in the NRMP’s R3 system. You have until 9 p.m. EST on the final submission date in late February to create, modify, and certify your Rank Order List. Be sure to rank programs in order of preference, not based on perceived chances.

Submit and Certify: After carefully ranking your programs, certify your list by the deadline. Once certified, you can still make changes up until the deadline if needed.

Additional Tip: To maximize your chances of matching, rank all the programs at which you interviewed. Only consider leaving a program unranked if you would rather go unmatched than train at that program., and avoid ranking programs where you wouldn’t want to train​.

Expert Insights NRMP Rank Order List

In a recent webinar by Dr. Pedram Mizani, several expert examples were provided to help applicants craft a strategic NRMP Rank Order List.

Track Program History
Pay close attention to a program’s history, especially if it has unfilled positions. Programs that consistently struggle to fill slots might have underlying issues, such as lack of resident support or a challenging work environment. Similarly, high turnover or instances of residents leaving prematurely can be red flags. Investigate these issues and check if the program has implemented changes.
Pro Tip: Use resources like FREIDA to examine program statistics, including the number of unfilled positions over time. Speaking with current residents can provide valuable insights into the program’s culture and true atmosphere.

Post-Interview Communication

Note how programs communicate with you post-interview. Personalized, thoughtful responses can indicate genuine interest, while generic responses may signal a less invested approach. However, be cautious about reading too much into these communications, as programs are prohibited from revealing exact rankings. Focus on your impression during the interview itself rather than on post-interview signals.
Additional Insight: Keep in mind that enthusiastic post-interview feedback doesn’t guarantee ranking. Rely on your overall impression rather than these follow-ups.

Beware of Generic Feedback

Programs often send messages like “We intend to rank you highly,” but these can be sent to multiple applicants. Instead of being influenced by such feedback, rely on your gut feeling and the information gathered during interviews.
Pro Tip: Focus on how the program made you feel during the interview process. If a program felt like a good fit, prioritize it on your list regardless of post-interview messages.

Additional Tips for Success:

• Program-Specific Questions: During research or interviews, ask questions that matter to you. Topics like work hours, wellness initiatives, and support for residents can help you gauge the program’s culture and support systems.
• Length of Your Rank Order List: Data from the NRMP shows that applicants who rank more programs have a higher chance of matching. The median number of ranked programs for matched U.S. allopathic seniors is around 11, while those ranking fewer than 5 have lower chances.
• SOAP Participation: In case you don’t match, understanding the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) and having a contingency plan is essential. Register for SOAP and familiarize yourself with participating programs in case you need to pursue this option.

Post-Submission: What to Expect

Timeline Leading to Match Day 2025

Match Week for 2025 begins on Monday, March 10, 2025. On that day, applicants will find out if they’ve matched but won’t yet know where. If you are fully matched, you can breathe a sigh of relief and prepare for Match Day on Friday, March 14, 2025, when you will receive your official residency match details at 12 p.m. ET.

If you don’t match or are partially matched, you will enter the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP), which begins on Monday, March 10 at 10 a.m. ET and runs until Thursday, March 13, 2025. During SOAP, unmatched applicants can submit up to 45 applications to programs with unfilled positions​.

The SOAP Process

SOAP is an intense, fast-moving process designed to help unmatched applicants secure a residency position. After discovering you’re unmatched on Monday, you’ll need to submit applications immediately, as programs start reviewing them on Tuesday, March 11, 2025, at 8 a.m. ET. Interviews happen on Wednesday, and offers are extended on Thursday​. Staying organized and ready to respond quickly is crucial during this week.

Coping with Uncertainty

Uncertainty during Match Week is common, but managing your stress effectively can make a huge difference. Avoid comparing yourself to others, especially on social media, as it can heighten anxiety. 

Instead, focus on controlling the aspects you can, like preparing your SOAP applications, reaching out to advisors for guidance, and leaning on your support network. Keep in mind that being open to different specialties or locations can lead to new and unexpected opportunities​.

Conclusion

In conclusion, crafting your NRMP Rank Order List is crucial in securing residency programs. By reflecting on your priorities, thoroughly researching programs, balancing dream programs with realistic options, and considering geographic and lifestyle factors, you can create a rank list that maximizes your chances of matching to a program that will be ideal for you and ensures long-term success. 

We understand that this can be one of the most stressful decisions in your medical journey. Personalized guidance can help reduce that anxiety by giving you the tools to craft the perfect rank list confidently. 

Don’t wait—schedule your free 1:1 consulting today to ensure your rank list reflects your true goals and gives you the best chance of matching. Take control of your residency journey with expert guidance from Jack Westin.